In brief
Maxime Chapoutier, a notable French winemaker, has introduced two new wines blending French grapes with Australian varieties, making them illegal in France due to strict EU regulations. The wines, Hemispheres Red and Hemispheres White, are available in the UK, prompting discussions about the merging of terroir principles with global influences in the wine industry.
Maxime Chapoutier, a prominent French winemaker, has taken a bold step by introducing two new wines that defy traditional regulations in France, stirring considerable debate within the industry. If Chapoutier were to sell these two bottles — a white and a red — in his homeland, he would face arrest for their illegality. “There would likely be outrage about these wines in France, and that would be a good thing,” he asserts, emphasizing that sometimes provocation is necessary to initiate change.The controversy stems from Chapoutier's decision to blend French and Australian base wines, a practice strictly forbidden under both French and European Union laws. In France, the revered concept of "terroir" — which encompasses the environmental conditions that influence the character of the wine — lends an elevated status to wine produced exclusively in designated regions. As a result, the concept of combining grapes from different continents horrifies many traditional French wine enthusiasts.However, thanks to Brexit, Chapoutier found an opportunity to sell these blended wines in the UK without adhering to EU regulations. Collaborating with UK online retailer The Wine Society, he developed Hemispheres Red and Hemispheres White, with the red wine crafted from syrah, also known as shiraz in Australia, and the white wine composed of marsanne and viognier grapes. The Australian wine components are imported in bulk to the UK, where they are skillfully blended with French wines from the northern Rhône and Roussillon regions.Chapoutier, who represents a family heritage in winemaking that spans over 200 years, acknowledges the significance of terroir but advocates for the inclusion of global blends to cater to modern consumers. “More people are turning their backs on French wines because they find the complicated appellation rules prohibitive,” he comments, highlighting a need for greater accessibility in the market. He also notes the ecological advantages of bulk shipping over traditional bottled shipping.Other wine producers are joining the trend of creating blends from grapes sourced across continents. The Australian firm Penfolds has been marketing wines combining grapes from multiple regions, although these blends are similarly prohibited in the EU. As established producers like Penfolds label their offerings as "wine of the world," fears regarding the potential dilution of wine quality have surfaced, especially among traditionalists.Independent winemaker Jas Swan expresses concern that these cross-continental blends could lead to poor-quality wines devoid of any terroir significance. Meanwhile, industry experts like Peter Richards, a master of wine, share apprehensions about novelty for its own sake overshadowing quality in the quest for innovation.Conversely, wine writer Jamie Goode embraces the exploration of two-continent blends, provided they are made from quality grapes in skilled hands. He asserts that there's indeed expertise involved in the intricate blending process which could yield impressive outcomes.As part of The Wine Society’s 150th-anniversary celebration, Chapoutier's innovative wines challenge entrenched norms in the wine world. Pierre Mansour, head of buying for The Wine Society, emphasizes sustainability in their decision to create these wines, reflecting on how blending can offset climate challenges while remaining mindful of environmental impacts. Despite anticipated objections from traditionalists, the collaboration with Chapoutier was met with enthusiasm, hinting at a potential shift in the perception of wine production practices.




