Skip to main content
WorldVoice 360

Gaza's Esteemed Scholar Issues Historic Fatwa Against Hamas's October Attack

A prominent Islamic scholar in Gaza has condemned Hamas’s attack on October 7, 2023, marking a significant moment in the ongoing conflict.

Source: bbc.co.uk2 min read
Gaza's Esteemed Scholar Issues Historic Fatwa Against Hamas's October Attack
Image via bbc.co.uk

In brief

Professor Dr. Salman al-Dayah, a respected figure in Gaza, has issued a fatwa opposing Hamas's October 7 attack on Israel, arguing that it contradicts Islamic principles of jihad. This unprecedented ruling may challenge Hamas's justification for violence and stir debates about armed conflict in Palestinian society.

In a rare and powerful statement, Professor Dr. Salman al-Dayah, Gaza's leading Islamic scholar and a former dean at the Islamic University of Gaza, has issued a fatwa condemning Hamas's attack on Israel on October 7, 2023. This event initiated a brutal conflict in the region, marking a pivotal moment in Gaza's history. The fatwa carries significant weight among Gaza’s two million predominantly Sunni Muslim population, illustrating the deep divisions within the society regarding the role of armed resistance.Dr. Dayah's six-page legal opinion criticizes Hamas for allegedly violating essential Islamic principles governing jihad, which encompasses both personal and military struggle. He asserts that when the foundational principles of jihad are disregarded, the resulting violence only leads to loss of innocent lives, calling for a reevaluation of the political strategies used by Hamas leaders. The scholar emphasizes that the significant civilian casualties resulting from Hamas's attack and Israel's subsequent military response contradict the fundamental teachings of Islam. He urges that leaders are responsible for the protection of non-combatants, asserting that human life should be prioritized above all else. His fatwa represents a potentially damaging indictment against Hamas, especially as the group frequently invokes religious justification for its actions to rally support from Muslim communities.The October 7 attack resulted in the deaths of approximately 1,200 people and left hundreds taken hostage, leading Israel to launch a military campaign against Hamas. The ensuing violence has resulted in over 43,400 casualties in Gaza, according to reports from local health authorities. Dr. Dayah has pointed out that such outcomes are in direct violation of the moral and legal expectations outlined in Islamic teachings regarding the conduct of jihad.Dr. Dayah is known for his moderate Salafist beliefs, which oppose Hamas's brand of armed resistance and its affiliations with Shia entities like Iran. His critique of extremist ideologies includes a call for the establishment of an Islamic caliphate grounded in strict adherence to Islamic law, as opposed to the divisive political systems that Hamas promotes. This fatwa is likely to intensify the ongoing internal discussions within Gaza and across the Arab world about the legitimacy and consequences of Hamas's tactics. Sheikh Ashraf Ahmed, a student of Dr. Dayah who fled Gaza City due to the violence, praised the legal opinion as a significant and well-researched document. He highlighted Dr. Dayah's commitment to Islamic jurisprudence and the importance of the fatwa during this turbulent period.As the debate continues, the implications of Dr. Dayah’s fatwa may influence future strategies within Palestinian society regarding the use of militant resistance in the conflict with Israel.

Topics

More on this story