In brief
The investigation into the Air India Flight 171 tragedy, which claimed 260 lives, has revealed disturbing evidence related to fuel-control switches and cockpit communications, igniting critical questions regarding pilot actions and potential faults.
Investigators have made a startling discovery in the preliminary probe into the Air India Flight 171 crash that resulted in 260 fatalities in June. Just moments after takeoff, the fuel-control switches of the 12-year-old Boeing 787 Dreamliner unexpectedly switched to the "cut-off" position, cutting off fuel supply and leading to complete power loss. Notably, this is a maneuver typically performed after landing. Cockpit voice recordings display a perplexing exchange, with one pilot questioning the other's why he "did the cut-off," to which the response was that he did not do it. The ambiguity in the recording leaves investigators grappling with the dynamics in the cockpit at the time. The co-pilot was at the controls during takeoff, while the captain oversaw flight operations.After the switches were reset to inflight mode, engines attempted to relight, but by that moment, the aircraft had already plunged into a densely populated area in Ahmedabad, India, less than 40 seconds after takeoff. This incident marks one of India's most mysterious aviation catastrophes, and the ongoing investigation, involving Indian authorities and experts from Boeing, General Electric, Air India, and international regulators, aims to shed light on the event.As investigators scrutinize the wreckage and cockpit recordings, lingering questions arise. Fuel lever switches are engineered to avoid accidental activation, necessitating a complex maneuver to toggle them, raising suspicions around unintentional or intentional actions by the flight crew. Air accident experts have pointed out that it's improbable for both switches to trigger by a single hand movement, adding a layer of complexity to the incident."It's concerning that a pilot would switch off the fuel switch shortly after takeoff," remarked former accident investigator Shawn Pruchnicki, who underscored the absence of pilot reports of anything amiss prior to the cut-off. Cockpit confusion typically manifests through observable communication patterns, which were notably absent in this scenario.Peter Goelz, former managing director of the NTSB, echoed the alarming nature of the findings, emphasizing the critical need for proper identification of the voices on the recording to ascertain responsibility for the actions that led to the crash. The cockpit's voice recorder, including sounds from pilot mics, radio communications, and cockpit ambience, is anticipated to be integral in uncovering the nuanced details surrounding the events leading up to the disaster. Investigators are advocating for enhanced measures such as cockpit video recorders to provide a fuller picture.Prior to stepping onto Flight 171, all pilots and crew members underwent breathalyzer tests, confirming their fitness for duty. The report noted that the pilots had adequate rest after arriving in Ahmedabad the day before the flight.Moreover, investigators highlighted a significant point regarding the safety of the fuel control switches, referencing a past advisory from the FAA in December 2018 about some Boeing models. While dealing with operational guidelines, Air India did not complete recommended evaluations, leading to questions about potential risks.As the scrutiny of the crash continues, the inability to promptly identify the roles of the pilots in the cockpit remains a significant concern. Investigators are pushing for clarity and a thorough review of communications from the moment the aircraft left the ground until the tragic outcome, aiming to explain the perplexing circumstances that led to the crash and prevent future occurrences.

