In brief
The proposed amendments to the Waqf Act, which governs properties worth millions donated by Muslims in India, have incited significant opposition from various Muslim groups, resulting in protests nationwide. The legislation, aiming to amend an existing law that has been in place for decades, is touted by Prime Minister Narendra Modi's government as a necessary step to eliminate corruption within waqf management. These waqf properties, which encompass mosques, madrasas, and land, are viewed as charitable donations for communal benefit, unable to be sold or repurposed.
Despite acknowledging corruption issues in waqf boards, critics argue that the proposed bill is politically driven, aimed at undermining the rights of Muslim minorities while prioritizing governance by non-Muslims in these boards. With the bill postponed for further recommendations from a parliamentary committee, many are concerned about the potential ramifications for historical and community properties tied to Islamic traditions that have existed for generations. Experts warn the changes could significantly diminish Muslim control over waqf assets and may lead to increased encroachments.Muslims in India assert that while reform calls are valid, it must respect their community's interests as the ongoing debate unfolds, highlighting a critical intersection of governance, faith, and identity.The article text:Several Muslim groups across India are vocally opposing proposed amendments to the decades-old Waqf Act, governing millions of dollars’ worth of properties donated by Indian Muslims. These properties, including mosques, madrasas, graveyards, and thousands of acres of land, are regarded as waqf — charitable or religious donations made for the benefit of the community. They cannot be sold or repurposed, indicating that such properties belong to God.The new bill, which includes over 40 amendments aimed at reforming the management of waqf properties, was anticipated to be presented in this parliamentary session after receiving inputs from a joint committee of Members of Parliament (MPs). However, the committee is now requesting additional time to offer its recommendations.The Modi government's justification for the proposed changes hinges on rooting out corruption within waqf management and responding to reform demands from the Muslim community. Despite this, numerous Muslim organizations and opposition parties have lambasted the amendments as politically motivated. They contend that these changes signify an effort by Modi's Hindu nationalist party to undermine minority rights.The Waqf system in India dates back to the 12th Century, initiated during the Delhi Sultanate when early Muslim rulers began to establish waqf properties. Presently, the Waqf Act of 1995 governs these properties, establishing state-level boards comprising representatives such as government nominees, Muslim lawmakers, and Islamic scholars.With an estimated 872,351 waqf properties collectively valued at 1.2 trillion rupees ($14.22 billion; £11.26 billion), the government asserts that these boards represent one of India's largest landholding entities. Although Muslim groups acknowledge corruption as a pressing issue within waqf boards—often implicated in collusion with encroachers—the debate on the necessity for reform becomes complex due to historical encroachments involving individuals, businesses, and government entities.Research from the 2006 Justice Sachar Committee indicated the underperformance of waqf boards, estimating the potential annual revenue generation from these properties could reach 120 billion rupees (approximately $1.4 billion; £1.1 billion), contrasting sharply with current estimates closer to 2 billion rupees.Despite acknowledging corruption issues, the proposed amendments incite deep skepticism among many Muslims, particularly regarding changes to ownership rules that could affect historically significant mosques and graveyards. Many of these properties lack formal documentation because they were donated informally or without legal records centuries ago. The 1954 Waqf Act acknowledged such properties under “waqf by user,” but the new proposals do not include this provision, leading to uncertainty for numerous properties tied to community heritage.Concerns are escalating regarding potential impacts on Muslim control over waqf properties, particularly with a requirement for non-Muslims to be included on waqf boards. Some advocate for secular governance of religious institutions, yet critics assert that these changes signal a favoring of majoritarian politics and an encroachment by the state over Muslim community assets.Additional proposed amendments involve obligatory registration of waqf properties with district collectors, who would need to validate claims to these properties, a move that critics argue could diminish the authority of waqf boards. Asaduddin Owaisi, a prominent Muslim MP, claims that the amendments are designed to dispossess Muslims of their land. Currently, government data indicate that around 58,889 waqf properties are encroached upon with more than 13,000 embroiled in legal disputes.As the debate continues, stakeholders emphasize the necessity for reforms that honor the sensitivities and interests of the Muslim community while striving for equitable land management.